What is Your Favorite Desktop?

by Susan Linton - Mar. 02, 2011Comments (8)

Desktop LinuxEvery few years I run a poll on my personal website to gauge Linux users' favorite desktop. When analyzing the results over the years, some trends do emerge. Is KDE or GNOME king? What has come in third or fourth consistently over the years? How about you, what is your favorite desktop?

The first poll was taken in November of 2005 and received 1234 responses. The second was in June 2008 and got 1502 votes. The latest got 1701 votes last month.

KDE and GNOME were always the two top favorites. In 2005 KDE got 53% of the votes while GNOME received 27%. In 2008 KDE got 46% and GNOME 39%. Last month KDE earned 41% of the vote in contrast to GNOME which got 37%. We can conclude that for a while GNOME was catching up with KDE as it gained in popularity while KDE declined. This could probably be attributed to the rise of Ubuntu and the release of KDE 4. But the anomaly of GNOME's recent slight recline could reflect on diminishing use of Ubuntu in response to their move to Unity or perhaps users are moving to other desktops again in response to the move to Unity. We can only speculate. However, it is interesting to note that the new addition, Unity, to the poll this year netted a 2% take. While that would make up the decrease in GNOME this year, KDE still decreased as well by 5%.

The interesting numbers for KDE and GNOME make the third, fourth, and fifth placements even more relevant. Xfce came in third all three years of polling. In 2005 it got 8% of the vote, 6% in 2008, and 6% in 2011. So while it lost 2% between 2005 and 2008, it remained the same this year as it did in 2008. Could that 2% have moved to GNOME?

The fourth position reflects another new addition to the poll choices this year. LXDE made its debut last month and earned 5% of the vote. In previous years the fourth position was held by the *box term. This encompasses Fluxbox, OpenBox, Blackbox, and all the other *boxes. In 2005 it got 8% of the vote and 4% in 2008. This year it received 3%. Even though LXDE entered the market, it probably didn't put too much of a dent into *box usage. Something else caused a more significant decline between 2005 and 2008. One might be tempted to suggest those users probably moved to GNOME as well.

In 2005 Enlightenment came in sixth with 3% behind Other which got 4%. In 2008 it received 3% again, but that time ahead of Other with 2%. This year it tied with Other and *box with 3% of the vote. Enlightenment user numbers have remained consistent over the years.

So, we can conclude that KDE is still hanging on to the lead amongst visitors to my website. I'd like to think it's a good representation of Linux users in general, but other polls have put GNOME in the lead or tied. For example, in the last Linux Journal's Readers' Choice Awards taken in late 2010, KDE and GNOME tied. In 2008, Linux Journal found that GNOME surpassed KDE with 45.7% of the vote to KDE's 42.5%. In 2005, KDE came in first and GNOME second; no percentages were published.

LinuxQuestions.org runs a poll every year on many aspects of open source software. In 2005 KDE was the winner with 64.86%. In 2008 KDE had a slight lead with 43.57% of the vote while GNOME got 40.39%. KDE was way down in 2010 with only 33.05% of the vote with GNOME pulling ahead with 45%.

So, no matter the source, KDE has been in decline the last several years and GNOME has been rising in popularity. Few would argue that was due to Ubuntu. Next year's results will be even more interesting given Ubuntu's move to Unity.


The Numbers


Desktop    2005    2008    2011   
KDE 53% 46% 41%
GNOME 27% 39% 37%
Xfce 8% 6% 6%
LXDE - - 5%
*box 8% 4% 3%
Enlightenment 3% 3% 3%
Unity - - 2%
Other 4% 2% 3%


Abhijit Prabhudan uses OStatic to support Open Source, ask and answer questions and stay informed. What about you?


I can only talk about my case here. I've started using Linux about a year ago and as most of new users we probably first hear about Ubuntu since it has the most propaganda. About two months ago I started looking around at other Linux distros and different desktops. I soon found out that there are both, better distributions and better desktops. So in the end I ended up with KDE 4.5 on Mandriva Linux. I also liked openSUSE with KDE a lot but it is not as user friendly as Mandriva. (still much better than Ubuntu though). So I guess after getting our feet wet with Linux and getting used to it we are now ready to discover other parts of the huge Linux land.

0 Votes

You tell little about how the poll was taken, making the data nearly useless. The only conclusions that can be drawn are regarding the users visiting your site.

Perhaps there are reasons why less kde users visit your site now: article content, topics, etc. Or perhaps your results are similar to an actual trend across all linux users. But you don't know, I don't know, and none can say.

0 Votes

Our LUG does monthly installfests and we offer both desktops so people can test them and see which feel more confortable (we dont give choice for old hardware going with what works best alhtough Puppy is a big hit).

The past two years (since I joined) our numbers are between 60 an 70% for KDE.

Its very simple, while KDE doesnt copy XP or Vista necessarily, there are quite a few similarities that make the transition easier. The look and feel of the fonts are 'different' to many people and just enough things are done differently to make it feel different.

Its all about making people feel confortable in their Linux desktop so what better way to celebrate our choice than ACTUALLY giving people a choice.

(dont overdo it though).

But fanboism is such that seein a newb running another desktop for some is like watching their girlfriend doing it with another guy.

Its a desktop. Thats all.

0 Votes

If I may, I'd like to point out Pinguy OS. It's a fine looking desktop. And my favourite one. Snowlinux is another..

As for the 'fanboyism' mentioned, well hey, any time an 'ism' is added to the end of a word, noun or adjective the original meaning goes out the window.

0 Votes

As much as I don't like using Microsoft, I find that KDE and Gnome are becoming very bloated, and slow.

I recently switched to LXDE on PCLinuxOS: very fast boot and applications open fast.

Operating Systems are starting to look like SUVs, I just need a good bicycle.

0 Votes

Why did you delete my comment, thats a little F'd up. You guys based in Liberia or something? Free speech - ever hear of it?

My original answer....Windows

0 Votes

Hi Jon - apologies - this may have happened in error. We only delete duplicate comments or spam comments, and sometimes, legit comments get caught up in our spam filters. Do re-post it, or send it to 'feedback [at] ostatic.com' and we'll make sure it gets up. Apologies for the inconvenience.

0 Votes

Would be curious to know where the conclusion that LXDE didn't put a dent in the *box market came from. LXDE is based on OpenBox. I can certainly see OpenBox users switching to LXDE or a subset of the utilities that come with for OpenBox. I run some of the LXDE utilities (such as lxtask and gpicview) myself. If a Linux distribution came with a LXDE version and I wanted to run an OpenBox window manager, I'd have no problem choosing the LXDE version rather than picking another version with a different desktop and then going back and installing OpenBox. So far, LXDE has been the lightest on resources and most responsive of all desktops I've tested on very old hardware (12 years old or more).

0 Votes
Share Your Comments

If you are a member, to have your comment attributed to you. If you are not yet a member, Join OStatic and help the Open Source community by sharing your thoughts, answering user questions and providing reviews and alternatives for projects.

Promote Open Source Knowledge by sharing your thoughts, listing Alternatives and Answering Questions!